In an unexpected turn of events, the state of Michigan is relinquishing possession of a valuable artifact linked to the historic Edmund Fitzgerald shipwreck. The artifact, a life ring from the ill-fated vessel, is being returned to Larry Orr, a key figure in this unusual saga. Despite the return of the life ring, the state has agreed to a $600,000 settlement to address a lawsuit filed by Orr concerning alleged police misconduct.
Larry Orr, 77, expressed relief over the resolution, stating, “I feel a whole lot better.” Orr recounted his discovery of the life ring and a portion of a lifeboat on the shores of Michigan’s Upper Peninsula just eight days after the tragic sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald in 1975, which claimed the lives of all 29 crew members. Orr vividly recalled the somber atmosphere and his fruitless search for any signs of survivors in the aftermath of the maritime disaster.
The recent developments trace back to a lawsuit filed by Orr against the Michigan State Police, specifically accusing Lt. David Busacca of rights violations during a misconduct investigation that was later discredited. Amid settlement negotiations, the state unexpectedly expressed interest in the Fitzgerald life ring, which Orr had in his possession. This twist in the proceedings led to a revision of the settlement amount, increasing it to $600,000 from an initial sum close to $300,000, as confirmed by Orr and his attorney, Shannon Smith.
Despite Orr’s sense of being maneuvered, financial constraints prompted him to include the life ring in the settlement deal. Following further discussions among legal representatives, a revised agreement was reached: Orr would regain ownership of the life ring, while the state would honor the $600,000 settlement to resolve the police misconduct lawsuit. This revised arrangement was later confirmed by a spokesperson for the state police.
For years, Orr had loaned the distinctive orange life ring, bearing the inscription “Fitzgerald,” to the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum in Paradise, Michigan. However, considering his current circumstances, Orr is contemplating selling the artifact at an auction to address pressing financial needs, including purchasing a modular home and addressing his wife’s ailing vehicle.
“This whole ordeal has left me in dire straits, and every bit of financial support is crucial at this point,” Orr expressed.