Inquiry Launched After Military Police’s Delayed Response to Suicide

Date:

Share post:

WARNING: This article includes mentions of suicide.

According to recently revealed evidence, military police took over six hours to perform a wellness check on a defense intelligence analyst in Ottawa after his wife expressed concerns for his well-being.

The suicide of Master Cpl. Shaun Orton in 2024 is the focus of an unusual public inquiry by Canada’s military police oversight body.

The Military Police Complaints Commission (MPCC) is investigating the situation due to the severity of the claims and the potential systemic issues regarding military police responses to mental health emergencies.

Upon arriving and finding Orton hanging, military police did not administer CPR, believing it was too late to assist, as indicated by testimony during the hearing.

Ottawa police arrived ten minutes later and attempted to revive him, but Orton was pronounced dead later at the hospital.

Sarah, Orton’s wife, contends that military police exhibited an unreasonable delay and failed to respond adequately.

During the MPCC hearing, her attorney, Catherine Christensen, pointed out a military police directive stating that unless “death is clearly evident,” efforts must be made to save a life.

“The preservation of life should be the top priority,” Christensen stated on April 20. “Officers must operate under the assumption that the individual is alive and take all necessary steps to preserve life.”

“The MPs present were aware of these orders. They did not follow them.”

A lawyer for a military police sergeant involved asserted that his actions were “guided by the institutional framework available to him.” He mentioned systemic challenges, such as insufficient staffing and vague, outdated instructions on wellness checks.

It is the responsibility of the military oversight body to determine whether any misconduct occurred and to provide recommendations for enhancing military policing across Canada.

Concerned wife initiated wellness check

Recently released call transcripts reveal that Sarah Orton contacted military police shortly after 9 a.m. on April 21, 2024, requesting a wellness check on her husband. She mentioned receiving multiple distressing messages from him throughout the night, indicating that he was “spiraling out of control and in need of help.”

“Now he’s not responding, and I’m just hoping someone can check on his mental health,” she told Sgt. Mathew Young, according to the call transcript.

Despite having moved out of town during a trial separation, Sarah Orton testified that she kept in regular contact with her husband.

On that day, she informed Young that it had been two hours since her husband had replied to her messages and that he had not answered several phone calls, as noted in the transcript of her call to military police.

Orton's wife, Sarah Orton, filed a complaint with the watchdog last year saying she told military police on April 21, 2024, she was concerned about her husband's safety after receiving 'disturbing communications' from him.

Sarah Orton lodged a complaint with the MPCC last year, expressing her worries about her husband after receiving ‘disturbing communications’ from him. (Submitted by Sarah Orton)

Young, familiar with Shaun Orton, inquired if he had expressed any intentions of self-harm; otherwise, he stated military police typically do not respond.

“Our usual protocol is to not respond unless… the individual indicates they plan to harm themselves or have a specific plan for doing so,” Young explained.

Young then provided Sarah Orton with a contact number for her husband’s unit, suggesting they would conduct the check, as per the call transcript. However, when she attempted to call, it went directly to voicemail, as it was the weekend. She was unable to reach anyone at other numbers she tried as well.

Sarah Orton testified that she ultimately sought assistance from civilian authorities.

Just before 2 p.m. that same day, Ottawa police Const. Parsons contacted Young to inquire why he had not carried out the wellness check, according to a transcript of their conversation. Parsons mentioned that Shaun Orton had experienced significant past trauma.

Young informed Parsons that he was acquainted with Shaun Orton and that only two officers were on duty to cover the entire National Capital Region, stating, “We’re very limited,” according to the call transcript.

Parsons remarked that police were “definitely concerned,” and a crisis worker involved in the case expressed a desire to conduct a door knock.

‘This is a real situation’

At 2:46 p.m., Sarah Orton called Young again, relaying that Ottawa police had advised her to remind him that “this is a real situation,” as per the call transcript.

She described similar messages Shaun Orton had sent around the time of a previous suicide attempt in 2019, expressing her deep concern.

“This isn’t my first experience with suicide in the military, and I’ve been dealing with this for 15 years, so I’m very worried about his health and well-being right now,” she stated.

After placing her on hold, Young agreed to check on her husband but reiterated that military police protocol was to refrain from action unless the individual specified intentions to harm themselves or others.

“I just need to know he’s okay,” Sarah Orton pleaded.

Master Corporal Shaun Orton switched from infantry to intelligence and was posted to Ottawa in 2015.

Master Corporal Shaun Orton was assigned to Ottawa in 2015. (Submitted by Sarah Orton)

Young arrived at Shaun Orton’s home at 3:33 p.m. — approximately six and a half hours after his wife’s initial call to military police, as revealed during the hearing.

Young testified that he believed it was too late to conduct CPR. He observed that Shaun Orton’s body was still warm but lacked a pulse.

According to a summary from Young’s pre-hearing interview, he had learned that purple extremities are signs of death through “true crime shows and online research.” When questioned about this during the hearing, Young stated he could not recall the exact source of that information.

Young testified that Ottawa police arrived ten minutes after he discovered Orton. They also found the body warm and decided to attempt CPR.

Orton was declared dead at the hospital around 5 p.m., as documented in hospital records.

Young testified that a military police directive regarding sudden death investigations stated that a body should not be moved, except to check for a pulse, to preserve the scene.

Young’s attorney, Phillip Millar, argued that his client’s initial decision not to perform the wellness check and to direct her to what he believed was the appropriate support channel was reasonable, given the circumstances. “The evidence will demonstrate that Sgt. Young directed Mrs. Orton to what he perceived to be the proper support resource, the Transition Unit.”

Once military police became aware of Orton’s prior suicide attempt and that civilian authorities had been unable to contact him, their assessment evolved, Millar noted.

“The information then included a history of prior suicide attempts and more urgent language indicating a serious and immediate crisis,” Millar stated during the April 20 hearing.

Millar added that the hearing’s evidence will show that Young was working in an understaffed environment with unclear and outdated verbal instructions regarding wellness checks.

Young testified that he had been verbally instructed that with only two personnel on duty, they should respond only to emergencies and defer other calls until the next day when more staff were available.

“The CAF established broader mental health and transition structures for a reason, and these systems were meant to ensure that a patrol officer on a weekend shift would not become the last line of defense for a complex, prolonged mental health crisis,” Millar stated.

The MPCC hearing is expected to continue until May 15.


If you or someone you know is experiencing difficulties, here are some resources for help:

Source

Related articles

Fresh Prep Foods Wins Court Approval to Acquire Struggling Goodfood

Fresh Prep Foods Inc., a Canadian meal delivery service, has announced that it has gained court approval to...

Balen Shah Dances to Victory as Nepal’s Youth Rally for Change

In Kathmandu on Saturday, a truck transporting Balendra Shah, a candidate for the Nepali prime ministership, was overwhelmed...

B.C. Holds Firm on U.S. Liquor Ban Amid Ongoing Trade Dispute

British Columbia will not restore U.S. products to B.C. Liquor Store shelves until the ongoing trade and tariff...

New Bridge in Prince George Aims to Protect Migrating Amphibians

As the lyrics suggest, being green is quite challenging.However, a newly constructed bridge that crosses an amphibian migration...