The government rejected Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre’s proposal for a new oil pipeline to the Pacific, emphasizing that this decision does not indicate a withdrawal from the recent agreement with Alberta. Poilievre’s motion, echoing parts of the pact between Prime Minister Mark Carney and Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, sought support for a pipeline transporting a million barrels of Alberta bitumen to Asia. The motion was defeated with 196 votes against and 139 in favor, as the Bloc, NDP, and Greens sided with the Liberals.
The Conservatives introduced the motion to highlight divisions within the Liberal party, suggesting potential risks to the pipeline project. Poilievre aimed to pressure Carney into demonstrating a commitment to pipeline construction. However, the government dismissed the motion as a political maneuver, emphasizing that it cherry-picks elements from the comprehensive agreement with Alberta.
Carney challenged Poilievre to present the entire memorandum for a vote in the Commons, underscoring that the pipeline’s construction hinges on fulfilling all terms of the deal. Despite amendments by Poilievre to address Indigenous co-ownership and collaboration with British Columbia, the Liberals indicated they would vote against the motion due to its omission of key environmental considerations agreed upon in the MOU.
The Liberal government reiterated its support for the pipeline project outlined in the MOU, emphasizing the importance of developing Canada’s natural resources amid economic challenges. However, Indigenous Services Minister Mandy Gull-Masty criticized the motion as disrespectful towards Indigenous Peoples, highlighting its failure to acknowledge crucial aspects regarding Indigenous consultation and rights in the agreement.
While the Conservatives accused the Liberals of ambiguity on the pipeline issue, Indigenous leaders expressed varying views on the project’s impacts. The proposed pipeline’s potential environmental risks and economic benefits divided opinions among Indigenous communities. Carney’s agreement with Alberta outlines plans for a privately funded pipeline with Indigenous co-ownership, aiming for expedited review and construction by 2029.
The government reaffirmed its commitment to the pipeline project, emphasizing the need for a comprehensive approach that considers environmental, Indigenous, and economic factors. Carney emphasized the importance of bold and swift action in advancing the country’s energy infrastructure.