Is “Eddington” considered a western film? According to writer/director Ari Aster, it certainly is. Despite being associated with previous films like “Midsommar,” “Hereditary,” and “Beau Is Afraid,” Aster has persistently labeled it as such in interviews.
Looking at the setting, “Eddington” undeniably embraces western elements as it unfolds in a fictional town in New Mexico, complete with the typical sand, Stetsons, and bolos characteristic of the genre. However, delving into the storyline reveals a departure from traditional western themes.
The narrative centers on Sheriff Joe Cross (played by Joaquin Phoenix), pitted against Mayor Ted Garcia (played by Pedro Pascal) in a conflict revolving around COVID-era mask mandates, escalating into a small-scale war. The film further explores subplots involving characters like a conspiracy-minded Etsy crafter (portrayed by Emma Stone) influenced by a QAnon-connected fraudster (played by Austin Butler).
Aster’s take on the western genre challenges conventional norms by intertwining elements like performative Black Lives Matter demonstrations and right-wing gun-rights activism. This unconventional approach distances “Eddington” from classic westerns like “Shane,” embodying a contemporary and complex narrative.
In an interview with TheWrap, Aster reflected on the evolving nature of the western genre, emphasizing its relevance amidst societal shifts. Historically, westerns have served as a reflection of American folklore, weaving narratives that mirror the country’s evolving identity and values.
“Eddington” diverges from the traditional portrayal of American settlement, portraying a town in decline during the 2020s. Phoenix’s portrayal of Sheriff Cross challenges the idealized image of a stoic American hero, as the narrative delves into themes of corruption and online polarization.
The film’s exploration of a new civilization symbolized by a looming data center introduces themes of technological progress and societal discord. As the town grapples with conflicting ideologies and impending change, “Eddington” underscores the struggle for understanding and unity in a rapidly transforming America.
Amidst a backdrop of shifting allegiances and moral ambiguity, “Eddington” presents a kaleidoscopic narrative that questions the core values of its characters. Ultimately, the film poses a poignant question about the American ethos: What does it mean to believe in something and strive for a better future in a society plagued by discord and disillusionment?
