First Nations Demand End to Indian Act’s Second-Generation Cut-Off

Date:

Share post:

Leaders and advocates from First Nations are urging the federal government to act on the United Nations’ recommendations to abolish the second-generation cut-off outlined in the Indian Act.

On Tuesday, the Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs and the Indian Act Sex Discrimination Working Group hosted a virtual press conference to elaborate on the technical guidance provided by the United Nations Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (EMRIP) to Canada.

EMRIP issued its ‘Technical Advice’ on May 2, recommending that Canada eliminate the second-generation cut-off, which restricts Indian status from being inherited by children after two generations of one parent holding status.

“Currently, Canada is failing to fulfill its obligation to consult and is instead disregarding the voices of First Nations leaders and women, which delays justice for our children,” stated Pam Palmater, a member of the Indian Act Sex Discrimination Working Group, during the press conference.

EMRIP provides advice to member states, such as Canada, on the complete implementation of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP).

The review regarding the second-generation cut-off and the Senate revisions to Bill S-2 was requested by Jeremy Matson of the Squamish Nation along with NDP MPs Leah Gazan and Jenny Kwan.

The review concluded that the second-generation cut-off violates Article 8 of UNDRIP, which forbids forced assimilation and cultural destruction.

“Canada cannot keep postponing justice while generations of First Nations families lose their status, identity, and rights under Canadian law,” Matson expressed.

“My family has endured these consequences firsthand for a century. We have spent years navigating systems that aim to erase us.”

Senate amendment

Last year, Bill S-2 was introduced in the Senate to resolve unresolved issues concerning the Indian Act and enfranchisement, following the British Columbia Supreme Court ruling in Nicholas v. Attorney General (Canada).

The Senate amended the bill to also eliminate the second-generation cut-off.

Currently, Bill S-2 is under review by the House Standing Committee on Indigenous and Northern Affairs, where over 40 witnesses have presented evidence, predominantly in support of the amended bill. However, some First Nations leaders oppose Bill S-2, arguing that it perpetuates federal control over identity definitions.

Indigenous Services Canada Minister Mandy Gull-Masty is advocating for an extended consultation period regarding the elimination of the second-generation cut-off.

On Friday, Gull-Masty announced that plans are in place to address the second-generation cut-off “in an expedited manner” this fall. In a statement to CBC Indigenous, her office mentioned that the government is dedicated to proposing legislative reforms “that align with the perspectives and priorities of First Nations.”

Palmater expressed doubt regarding the government’s capability to enact separate legislation concerning the second-generation cut-off, noting the absence of clarity or a timeline for consultations with First Nations on this issue.

“If this is the case, then legislation cannot possibly be introduced in the fall. Therefore, none of this instills confidence that there will be independent legislation,” Palmater remarked.

“If the goal is genuinely to eliminate sex discrimination, racial discrimination, and the second-generation cut-off, the Senate has already accomplished that for them.”

‘They have an opportunity now to act’

There are only four sitting weeks left for Parliament to pass the bill before the summer recess.

Marilyn Slett, chief councillor of the Heiltsuk Tribal Council and secretary-treasurer of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs (UBCIC), informed reporters that UBCIC has been advocating for the removal of the second-generation cut-off since its inception in Canada in 1985.

A woman in a burgundy shirt speaks on a Zoom call.

Marilyn Slett, chief councillor of the Heiltsuk Tribal Council and secretary-treasurer of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, expresses concern over delays in legislation aimed at removing the second-generation cut-off. (CBC)

Slett stated that UBCIC is worried about potential delays if Parliament adjourns before passing the bill or if a separate bill is introduced.

“The consultation they are initiating is inappropriate. We have decades of such consultations and recognize that the time to act is now,” Slett emphasized.

“They have a chance to act now and rectify the issues they created with the Indian Act and registration, and we understand that the timeframe is critical.”

Source

Related articles

Peace River Lifts Flood Warning, Residents Urged to Stay Alert

On Friday morning, officials in the northwestern Alberta community of Peace River lifted their warning regarding imminent flash...

Nurse Turns Passion for Horses into Healing Program for Youth

For Cheryl Tootoosis, her work with horses transcends mere interest; it represents a dedication to assisting individuals in...

Trump Dismisses Homeland Security Chief Noem, Nominates Mullin

On Thursday, U.S. President Donald Trump dismissed his beleaguered homeland security secretary, Kristi Noem, following escalating criticism regarding...

Xi calls for building Asia-Pacific community of shared prosperity

SHENZHEN, Nov 19, 2026— Chinese President Xi Jinping on Thursday called on Asia-Pacific economies to work together to...