Animal welfare activists are criticizing Marineland for its ultimatum to euthanize the 30 remaining beluga whales at its closed amusement park in Niagara Falls, Ontario, unless the government provides funding for their care or allows their export by Tuesday. World Animal Protection Canada is urging the provincial government to step in and take custody of the belugas to prevent their demise. Erin Ryan, wildlife campaign manager at the organization, expressed strong disapproval of Marineland’s attempt to pressure the Canadian government into a decision by using the threat of euthanasia. She emphasized that euthanasia should only be considered based on expert veterinary advice and the animals’ best interests, not as a cost-saving measure.
In a letter addressed to federal Fisheries Minister Joanne Thompson, Marineland highlighted its dire financial situation and inability to afford proper care for the belugas, following the government’s rejection of its export permit request. This plea for funding came after the denial of permits to send the belugas to a theme park in China. Marineland warned that the minister’s decision to withhold export permits would directly lead to the euthanasia of the captive-born belugas.
Regarding the funding crisis, Thompson stated that Marineland’s immediate request for federal assistance after being denied export permits was inappropriate. She reiterated that the government’s decision aligns with regulations aimed at preventing the exploitation of marine animals. Thompson stressed that Marineland is responsible for the belugas’ well-being, with the province playing a role in ensuring their proper care. She planned to discuss the situation with Marineland representatives.
Since 2019, nineteen belugas have died at Marineland, with the last orca passing away in 2023. The closure of Marineland this year, apart from pandemic-related shutdowns, raised concerns about the future of the remaining animals at the park. Animal advocates have long called for collaborative efforts between Marineland and government authorities to develop a comprehensive plan for the animals’ welfare. Suggestions include establishing a whale sanctuary in Nova Scotia and exploring legal options to hold Marineland financially accountable for the animals’ care.
Experts and activists, including Angela Fernandez and Andrew Trites, criticized Marineland’s ultimatum to euthanize the belugas as a drastic measure. They emphasized the need for exploring all available options, such as relocating the animals to suitable facilities or sanctuaries. Trites emphasized the importance of considering the belugas’ best interests and potential contributions to research and conservation efforts. Fernandez urged government intervention to protect the belugas and seek sustainable solutions that prioritize the animals’ well-being.
