Rujuta Kumthekar opts to stand when riding the TTC due to concerns about the cleanliness of the fabric seats, citing strange stains she has observed. She expresses a preference for plastic seats, noting their easier maintenance and cleaning process. Toronto’s transit system is currently debating the issue of seat materials, with plans to introduce plastic seats on new buses to enhance cleanliness.
Metrolinx, on the other hand, has chosen fabric seats for the new Eglinton and Finch light rail vehicles, emphasizing their comfort, durability, and ease of cleaning. The fabric used is a wool material known as moquette, which, despite being prone to stains, holds a symbolic significance in cities like London. In comparison, Toronto’s current transit seat design features plain red fabric, lacking the distinctiveness of other transit systems.
Helen Kerr, the designer behind Eglinton’s fabric seat pattern, aimed to create a visually appealing and functional design that can withstand spills and dirt. The chosen pattern reflects the colors of different transit agencies in the Greater Toronto Area, symbolizing transit system harmonization. While some argue for the comfort of fabric seats, others prioritize cleanliness, prompting discussions on the hygienic benefits of plastic versus fabric seats.
Geneticist Christopher Mason, who examines microbial ecosystems on subway surfaces, finds that both fabric and plastic seats harbor harmless bacteria and viruses commonly found on human skin. Despite finding more microbial diversity on fabric seats, Mason suggests that exposure to various surfaces is beneficial for the immune system. The TTC is gradually transitioning to plastic seats on buses, with potential plans to introduce them on the subway as well to address cleanliness concerns.
In conclusion, the debate between plastic and fabric seats in Toronto’s transit system continues, with considerations for both comfort and hygiene. While some commuters appreciate the comfort of fabric seats, others prioritize cleanliness and ease of maintenance, highlighting the importance of maintaining a balance between aesthetics and practicality in transit seat designs.