The family of a deceased Windsor woman is requesting the removal of photos depicting her during a period of substance abuse from social media. Alicia Newman, who passed away a few years ago, is the subject of these images. Her relatives express that these photos are distressing for them, and they prefer her to be remembered in a more positive light. Despite their attempts to contact the photographer for removal, their requests have been disregarded.
Alicia’s twin brother, Devin Newman, fondly remembers his sister as a kind-hearted individual who faced challenges after a serious car accident while living in Paris, Ont. Introductions to drugs by acquaintances led her into a tumultuous phase. Upon relocating to Windsor in her late twenties, Alicia struggled with addiction, homelessness, and mental health issues. Tragically, she passed away in 2018 due to drug-related complications.
Photographer Donnie Johnston has been unresponsive to the family’s pleas to remove the images of Alicia, which have been reposted on social media over the years. The family finds it particularly distressing to see these photos, including one with a caption insinuating Alicia’s involvement in sex work, circulating online. Despite efforts to report the images, they have not been successful in having them taken down.
The family emphasizes that Alicia did not consent to these photos, especially considering her bipolar disorder and vulnerable state. They are speaking out not only to reclaim Alicia’s narrative but also to protect others from potential exploitation online. Concerns have been raised about the lack of legal protection for vulnerable individuals in Canada, particularly those struggling with addiction.
While it may not be illegal to photograph individuals in public spaces in Canada, there are growing calls for more nuanced privacy laws, especially concerning vulnerable populations. Legal experts are closely monitoring international developments, such as Denmark’s proposal to grant individuals copyright protection over their digital identities. Strengthening legal frameworks to safeguard dignity and image control in the digital age is deemed essential by experts.
Addressing the ethical aspects of street photography, a photography expert stresses the importance of respecting the dignity and privacy of subjects, especially marginalized groups like the homeless. While raising awareness is crucial, it should not come at the expense of individuals’ dignity. Alicia’s family continues to advocate for the removal of the photos but express frustration at feeling powerless in this situation. They emphasize that Alicia would not want to be remembered for her struggles.